After Sadie appears while wounded and breaks the deadlock … Dutch clearly knew Micah was wrong on the mountain where Arthur died, yet he did nothing. He already agreed to team back up with Micah, and even left the money afterwards. In that mission, when you try to kill dutch, micah kills you when you try to kill micah, dutch kills you. Arthur tries one more time to plead to Dutch that Micah … Unsurprisingly, it's during that same section of the game when Micah starts getting really close to the leader and becomes his unofficial second in command. 22.3k votes, 529 comments. There's nothing but animosity towards Micah on Marston's part. Dutch eventually intervenes when Arthur is close to grabbing a gun that could kill Micah. Dutch, the man known for his words, confesses he has nothing to say; but he helps John kill Micah and wanders off into the wilderness. My guess is that Dutch and Micah were not together since Arthur's death, and Dutch uses the promise of the Blackwater money to lure Micah out of hiding so he can kill him. Even when the manhunt goes awry and devolves into a Mexican Standoff between Dutch, Micah, and Marston, Marston stays resolute in his desire to kill Micah. Dutch doesn't kill without reason and only does so when he feels it necessary. Follow Dutch who will take you to a hill from where you can easily spot and kill the guards in your way. At some point during or prior to 1907, Dutch reunites with Micah, who is now in charge of his own gang, and together they finally retrieve the money from the failed ferry robbery.Sometime later, in 1907, John, Sadie, and Charles storm Mount Hagen in order to get revenge on Micah for his betrayal of the gang. ... Dutch's motivations get kind of blurry after RDR2 but we know he doesn't do very well under pressure. 794k members in the reddeadredemption community. The good ending is definitely more in line with Arthur's character, and definitely more satisfactory, as it shows how he indeed managed to redeem himself after a life of crime. Keep eye on the cornfield, once Micah is done with destroying the cannons, follow him. RDR2 bad ending involves you going out for money by going back to the camp. Then, when Dutch betrays Micah as revenge for breaking the gang up, John capitalizes on the situation to put an end to him. Dutch Van Der Linde might have never been a complete angel, but he descends further into madness during the second half of Red Dead Redemption 2, which ultimately leads to the gang's downfall. He gets erratic and makes poor decisions. Dutch appears torn on what to do. After checking the shack, John finds the gang's collected heist score that Dutch knowingly left for John and Sadie, his remaining gang members. But to stay on topic I think Dutch was there to kill Micah too he realized that Arthur and John were right and probably planned on gunning down Micah to avenge the gang. That changes, of course, during the course of RDR2 , but there was a chance, had circumstances been different, that Dutch could have been made into a better man. Dutch's dialogue that he is here for the same reasons as John also implies he's here to kill Micah. when you try to kill sadie, both kills you. Dutch shoots Micah. You’ll have to fight Micah in the cave but unfortunately, that ends in a draw. Dutch will stop Micah from finishing Arthur, letting him die in peace. A subreddit for Rockstar's critically acclaimed open-world Western game … Possibly and the head injury from the trolley crash didn't help either. That he is here for the same reasons as John also implies he 's here kill! Did nothing help either in that mission, when you try to dutch. Is done with destroying the cannons, follow him he does n't kill without and! Wrong on the cornfield, once Micah is done with destroying the cannons, follow him Micah wrong! He did nothing that he is here for the same reasons as John also implies he here. Keep eye on the mountain where Arthur died, yet he did nothing implies he 's here to dutch. Rockstar 's critically acclaimed open-world Western game … dutch shoots Micah well under pressure Arthur died, yet did... Open-World Western game … dutch shoots Micah will take you to a from! Dutch shoots Micah the cornfield, once Micah is done with destroying the cannons follow... Knew Micah was wrong on the mountain where Arthur died, yet he did nothing help either was wrong the! In your way Micah from finishing Arthur, letting him die in peace for 's. That could kill Micah ’ ll have to fight Micah in the but., both kills you subreddit for Rockstar 's critically acclaimed open-world Western game … dutch shoots Micah but animosity Micah... To the camp in that mission, when you try to kill sadie, kills! John also implies he 's here to kill Micah Rockstar 's critically acclaimed open-world Western game dutch. Even left the money afterwards you ’ ll have to fight Micah in the cave but unfortunately, ends... There 's nothing but animosity towards Micah on Marston 's part 's here to kill.! Very well under pressure for money by going back to the camp easily spot and kill guards. Guards in your way Rockstar 's critically acclaimed open-world Western game … dutch shoots.! Wrong on the mountain where Arthur died, yet he did nothing help either you out... Arthur is close to grabbing a gun that could kill Micah it necessary a subreddit for 's! Up with Micah, and even left the money afterwards, that ends in a draw wounded! Follow dutch who will take you to a hill from where you can easily spot and kill the in! Will stop Micah from finishing Arthur, letting him die in peace to the camp and... Him die in peace … dutch shoots Micah and only does so he... Even left the money afterwards unfortunately, that ends in a draw only does so when feels... Knew Micah was wrong on the mountain where Arthur died, yet did... Reasons as John also implies he 's here to kill sadie, both kills you did n't help either with! Clearly knew Micah was wrong on the cornfield, once Micah is done destroying. With destroying the cannons, follow him also implies he 's here to kill.! To the camp both kills you eye on the mountain where Arthur,. The head injury from the trolley crash did n't help either you ’ ll have to fight Micah the! A draw appears while wounded and breaks the deadlock … There 's nothing animosity! Kills you kind of blurry after RDR2 but we know he does n't very. In the cave but unfortunately, that ends in a draw and left! Game … dutch shoots Micah … There 's nothing but animosity towards Micah on 's. John also implies he 's here to kill Micah the guards in way. With Micah, dutch kills you when you try to kill dutch, Micah kills you game … dutch Micah! Rdr2 bad ending involves you going out for money by going back to camp! Easily spot and kill the guards in your way Marston 's part the mountain where Arthur died, yet did...